Mondello Bakery

Photos

Reviews

• Daniel Rodriguez

  Nov, 27 2018
  ★ ★ ☆ ☆ ☆
  After reading these reviews...Not sure if they visited the same place I did. The staff are nice folks, and that’s as far I can agree on. I visited the store the week of Thanksgiving. I asked for a pound of butter cookies and asked the owner who was serving on me; “Are the butter cookies fresh? Because they are going to a doctor’s office and I don’t want to look bad.” She stated; “Yes, they are fresh.” Well when I got to the doctor’s office, I gave the receptionist the box and she opened it while we were having coffee. I nearly cracked my tooth biting into not one but tried several cookies. I took the box and apologized to the receptionist. Googled a nearby bakery and bought another pound. Night and day difference. I figured to give them a second chance, again the owner took care of me and I told her that I needed a birthday cake but had to be fresh. She recommended a strawberry shortcake and said it was fresh. Low-and-behold, it was so old and I was so embarrassed.
  Needless to say, I won’t be buying any sweets from this store. The Italian bread is great, but not had good experiences with the sweet stuff.

The nearest places

• Blue Point-Bayport Animal Hospital

  Establishment, Veterinary care

  765 Montauk Highway, Bayport, NY 11705

  +1 631-472-1101

  vcahospitals.com

  Closed now: Until 08:30am tomorrow
•  

  Furci Fine Foods

  Establishment, Food, Supermarket

  265 Snedecor Avenue, Bayport, NY 11705

  +1 631-419-0400

  furcispizza.com

  Closed now: Until 09:00am tomorrow
• Carvel

  Establishment, Food, Bakery

  776 Montauk Highway, Bayport, NY 11705

  +1 631-472-1994

  locations.carvel.com

  Closed now: Until 11:00am tomorrow
• Scorpio Beauty Salon

  Establishment, Hair care

  771 Montauk Highway suite 6, Bayport, NY 11705

  +1 631-868-7001

  scorpiobsalon.com

  Closed now:
• Kiddie Kampus West

  Establishment, School

  771 Montauk Highway, Bayport, NY 11705

  +1 631-472-5344

  kiddiekampuswest.com

  Closed now: Until 07:00am tomorrow
• Gluten Free Delivers

  Establishment, Health, Food, Supermarket

  Montauk Highway, Bayport, NY 11705

  +1 631-379-1545

  glutenfreedelivers.com

  Closed now: